Caramel Apple Pie

Print Recipe

caramel apple pie

We have an espalier apple tree in our backyard that appears to have been planted at the same time our house was built, so it should be somewhere in the neighborhood of 60 years old. This is the first year in the 4 that we have lived here that our apples haven’t been eaten to death by fungus. We finally got a lovely organic spray that worked well enough that we could enjoy the beautiful apples. Turns out they are amazing- very tart (which I love) and which means they are ideal for baking. Pete and the girls harvested bags and bags of them last week, and then it was what to do with them…

Caramel Apple Pie
(by the way- does this variety look familiar to anyone? I have no idea what it is?)

When I kicked off the Holiday season 10 days ago, I asked everyone what their favorite pie is. Answer after answer came back to apple pie. Lucky me. Something wonderful to do with all those bags of apples!

Apple pie is a tricky thing in my opinion. A bad apple pie is a serious bummer, bordering on disgrace, (is that too dramatic?) I loathe a big chunk of under cooked apple, and can’t stand a cornstarchy, goopy filling.

But a wonderful apple pie, with flaky crust and tender, spiced apple is heavenly.

caramel apple pie

Apple pie like the mother load of comforting desserts. But I just have such a hard time leaving good enough alone.

I had to take a beautiful apple pie and mess with it. And thank goodness I did.

caramel apple pie

By pouring a silky beautiful caramel sauce over super thinly sliced apples I created a lovely caramel apple pie that is sweet, lightly spiced and incredibly soft and tender.

This would make such a beautiful Thanksgiving pie, or a special treat for any weeknight dessert.

Caramel Apple Pie, serves 10
1 recipe Best Pie Crust
12 cups apples, peeled and THINLY sliced
½ cup sugar
¼ cup flour
1 tsp cinnamon
3 Tbs butter
1 cup vanilla caramel sauce

Vanilla Caramel Sauce, makes 2 cups
1 ½ cups sugar
1 ½ cups heavy cream
1 tsp vanilla paste

For the Caramel
1) In a medium saucepan, cook the sugar over medium-low heat.

2) After about 4-5 minutes the edges will have started to turn amber and bubble.

caramel apple pie caramel apple pie

3) Add the cream. (it will foam up and bubble and spit- be careful! and keep stirring.) Lower the heat to low and continue to cook for about another 10 minutes until the caramel is smooth (no sugar chunks) and all amber colored. **If it seizes up just continuously whisk until the sugar melts back in to the hot cream.

caramel apple pie caramel apple pie

4) Increase the heat to medium and stir and cook until the caramel is totally smooth, another 4-5 minutes.

caramel apple pie caramel apple pie

5) Remove the pan from the heat and stir in the vanilla paste.

caramel apple pie

6) Transfer the caramel sauce to a jar and refrigerate.

caramel apple pie

*Note: the sauce may seem pretty runny initially, but it will thicken up as it sits in the fridge.

caramel apple pie

7) In a large bowl, combine the apple slices, sugar, flour, cinnamon and butter. Toss to coat.

Caramel Apple Pie
Caramel Apple Pie
Caramel Apple Pie

8) Pile the apples in the prepared bottom piecrust. They will be Really high!

Coconut Pecan Pie
Caramel Apple Pie Caramel Apple Pie
Caramel Apple Pie

9) Pour the caramel sauce over the top of the apple slices.

Caramel Apple Pie

10) Stretch the other half of the piecrust over the top of the apples and caramel.
(my mom is doing this as I take pictures)
caramel apple pie caramel apple pie caramel apple pie caramel apple pie

11) If there are any bits of dough left, be sure to patch them over any tears.

12) With a forks tongs, poke some steam holes in the top of the pie.

caramel apple pie caramel apple pie

13) Place the whole pie on a sheet pan (it will leak apple and caramel juices), and loosely cover the entire top of the pie with a sheet of foil, (or the crust will brown too much)

14) Bake at 400 degrees for an hour.

15) Let cool before serving.

caramel apple pie caramel apple pie caramel apple pie caramel apple pie

caramel apple pie

“Come join Love the Pie with TidyMom sponsored by Whirlpool and enter to win a new Whirlpool Range”

Leave a Reply


  1. That pie sounds yummy! It must be our name (that we are thinking alike)- I made a caramel sauce and added it into shortbread cookies (to be posted tomorrow)!

  2. Im coming to your house for Thanksgiving Heather! Looks delish!

  3. LisaH says:

    Caramel and apple? In a pie? Oh heck yeah I’m making this for T-Day!

  4. Amy says:

    Oh my word…drooling over here. It’s so purty too.

  5. jenjenk says:

    FINE!! be that way – put the caramel in the apple pie…now i’m forced to try this! :)

    I’ve got a ton of apples, too so this will be perfect, although my apples aren’t too tart [fuji]

    • love fuji’s. lets be honest. i would not have cared if they had been honeycrisp. I still would have baked them into a pie with caramel :)

  6. I would adore a big slice of this pie!

  7. Katrina says:

    Mile high apple pie! Love it!

  8. Maria says:

    we both posted apple desserts today! Love this pie!

  9. Love the height on that pie! It is a mountain of delicious!

  10. Courtney says:

    ha! disregard my last comment ;) looks like you have more than enough.

  11. TidyMom says:

    Look amazing Heather!! lucky you having an apple tree right in your yard!!

    Hope you link this up to Love the Pie on Wed!!

  12. Lauren says:

    WHOA! That pie is HUGE!!

  13. two of my favorite things together in a pie — yum!

  14. marla says:

    Everything about this pie sounds amazing…mostly the fact that the tart apples are from you every own tree!

  15. Lucy Lean says:

    Love this dreamy apple pie – just curious that you don’t par-bake the crust before you pile all those apples in?

    • nope- that is where the 400 degrees for an hour come in…

  16. This looks phenomenal, Heather! I love seeing those sky high apples. :-)

  17. Ann says:

    There’s nothing quite like homemade caramel…what a BRILLIANT idea to put it on an apple pie!

    • Thanks Ann! I am a sucker for anything in caramel, and caramel+ apples seemed so great, I couldn’t help but bake it in a pie!

  18. What a gorgeous pie, it’s a real showstopper.

  19. I am drooling over this. I just dream of having an apple tree or some sort of fruit tree in my backyard when I own a house.

  20. Now that is an apple pie. Beautiful photos!

  21. Winnie says:

    WOW. I don’t usually like apple pie because it’s not exciting, but this recipe changes things! I am seriously considering this as one of our Tday desserts. With homemade bourbon vanilla ice cream. Mmmmmmm…..

    • thanks Winnie! nice compliment! I hope it makes the roster!

  22. Vicki B says:

    What a beautiful pie. Adding caramel is a fabulous idea!

  23. Chi Chi says:

    Hey, this looks fantastic! I make something similar every Thanksgiving but I add pecans…it’s delicious! I will try making caramel sauce from scratch, although I have to admit I am a little intimidated by just the thought of it! :)

    • no!! It is so easy! I promise you will never go back :)

  24. chloe says:

    This pie looks delicious! Do you think I would have to change too much if I used fewer apples?

    • nope- it just won’t be as high- no big deal!

  25. Shari says:

    Once again, your recipe didn’t disappoint…I made this pie last night and had a “second” Thanksgiving today…It was a huge hit! That pie crust was so flaky and delicious too!